Ten days after Hindu activists in Kandivali West’s Sanjay Nagar apprehended three individuals — including a South Korean national — allegedly offering ₹5–6 lakh to Hindus for converting to Christianity, the Kandivali police have yet to register a First Information Report (FIR), the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) has alleged.
The incident, which occurred on August 21 in the Sanjay Nagar area of Kandivali West, has sparked outrage among local Hindu organisations, who accuse the Kandivali police, under the jurisdiction of Police Inspector Karan Sonkawade, of dragging their feet under alleged political pressure.
The Incident
According to Jitendra Chaudhary, a local Hindu activist, and his associates, three individuals — a South Korean national who had come to Bharat on a student visa, and two Bharatiya nationals (a man and a woman) who had converted from Buddhism to Christianity — were conducting a “prayer meeting” in a residential building in Sanjay Nagar.
The trio allegedly approached Hindu residents, particularly women, and urged them to attend a Christian prayer programme. When some women declined, citing the ongoing holy month of Shravan and their devotion to Bhagvan Shiva, the missionaries allegedly mocked the Shivling, saying, “The Shivling is merely a stone. How can it be God?”
The activists further allege that the trio offered ₹5–6 lakh as an “inducement” for conversion, telling residents: “Come to our programme. All your illnesses will be cured. If you accept Christianity, you will receive ₹5–6 lakh.”
Confrontation and Police Handover
Jitendra Chaudhary and his friends recorded the conversation on their mobile phones. When confronted, the activists reportedly told the trio: “You cannot denigrate Hindu deities, and offering money as an inducement for religious conversion is a crime.” When asked, “Do you know an anti-conversion law has been enacted?” the missionaries reportedly fell silent.
Local activists of the Bajrang Dal and Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) were alerted and reached the spot. They detained the trio and handed them over to the Kandivali police station under the jurisdiction of PI Karan Sonkawade.
No FIR After 10 Days: VHP Alleges Police Inaction
Despite the handover and the submission of video evidence, no FIR has been registered as of August 31 — ten days after the incident.
VHP Mumbai unit functionaries have alleged that PI Karan Sonkawade is deliberately delaying the FIR under political pressure. They have demanded:
- Immediate registration of an FIR under relevant sections of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) and the Maharashtra Prevention of Conversion Act (if applicable), including sections pertaining to promoting enmity between religious groups, insulting religious beliefs, and inducement for conversion.
- Action against the South Korean national for violating visa conditions by engaging in religious proselytisation — a violation of Foreigners Act and visa norms.
- Action against the two Bharatiya converts for hate speech and inducement.
- Departmental inquiry against PI Karan Sonkawade for dereliction of duty.
A Hindu Perspective: Dharma, Consent, and the Rule of Law
For the Hindu tradition, dharma is not merely religion — it is the sustaining order that binds society through mutual respect, truth (satya), and non-coercion (ahimsa). The Shastras teach that faith arises from shraddhā — inner conviction — never from lobha (inducement) or bhaya (fear). To offer ₹5–6 lakh to a vulnerable family in Shravan, the month sacred to Shiva, and to mock the Shivling as “mere stone,” is not propagation of faith; it is adharma — a violation of the very freedom of conscience that Article 25 of the Constitution guarantees to every citizen, including the freedom from predatory proselytisation. Hindu society has historically absorbed, debated, and coexisted with every tradition that arrived on this soil — but always on the terms of samvāda (dialogue), never prabalana (allurement). When a foreign national on a student visa mocks the ishta-devata of his hosts and dangles cash for conversion, he breaches not only visa law but the ancient atithi-devo-bhava covenant that binds guest and host in mutual respect. The Vishwa Hindu Parishad’s demand is not for majoritarian dominance; it is for the even-handed application of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita and the Foreigners Act — laws that belong to every Indian, regardless of faith. If the police delay an FIR despite video evidence of hate speech and inducement, it is not merely procedural delay — it is a fracture in the rule of law that protects minorities and majorities alike. A Hindu perspective, rooted in Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam, insists: let every faith propagate peacefully, but let no law, visa, or political calculation shield those who trade in contempt and cash. Satyameva Jayate — truth alone prevails, but only when the law stands without fear or favour.
