After receiving positive feedback from a couple of close friends, I decided to watch Ramayana: Part 1 over the weekend. Since I’ve never been fond of 3D, I opted for a good 2D theater.
Before I proceed, let me clarify that I am not a professional movie reviewer. However, I appreciate good cinema and try my best not to criticize movies unnecessarily, especially when they are based on Bharat and its rich heritage. (Note: Minor spoilers ahead as I discuss specific scenes and sequences.)
With great anticipation, I settled in. Yet, barely ten minutes into the film, I began regretting my decision to skip the 3D version. Something felt missing from the very beginning. Within minutes, I realized that the audio effects were not quite up to expectations. Having experienced the scale and cinematic impact of films like Baahubali, RRR, Chhaava, and Dhurandhar, my expectations were understandably high, particularly given the enormous budget reportedly allocated to Ramayana.
By the 30-minute mark, it was clear that while the sound engineering was below par, the visuals were decent: good to watch, though not outstanding. The film introduces Ravana and Lanka early on before shifting the narrative to Ayodhya. Unfortunately, this is where the movie loses whatever momentum it built in its opening half-hour. By the 60-minute mark, I was genuinely frustrated by the lackluster manner in which one of our greatest epics was being brought to life.
Here is where I believe the film falls short:
- Performances: Ranbir Kapoor fails to transform into Sri Ram. For most of the runtime, he comes across as a generic action hero. While Sri Ram embodies profound inner calm and composure, Ranbir’s expressionless performance renders the character devoid of soul. Sai Pallavi, despite her proven acting abilities, feels entirely miscast as Sita. The principal standout is Yash as Ravana. In fact, the entire Lanka segment, which also benefits from the strong screen presence of Shobhana, Vivek Oberoi, and Rakul Preet Singh, carries the film.
- Visual Effects: The VFX are average at best. Given the scale of the production and the reported budget, the visual effects are surprisingly underwhelming. In the hands of a filmmaker like S.S. Rajamouli, one would have expected a far more spectacular visual experience. Much of what we see here feels uninspired and falls short of its potential.
- Execution & Pacing: Lanka is visually captivating and remains the film’s high point. Ayodhya, unfortunately, falls considerably short. Iconic moments such as the Sita Swayamvar fail to evoke the emotion and grandeur they deserve, while the lifting of Pinaka feels almost casually executed. The film even stumbles into unintentional comedy, such as a late-film sequence where Ram, Sita, and Lakshman are pursued by two asuras, executed so awkwardly that I found myself laughing out loud.
- Detailing & Costumes: The costume design in the Ayodhya sequences feels completely anachronistic. Women in Ayodhya are shown wearing modern blouses, and let’s not forget this was thousands of years ago. It was quite funny to watch Sita wearing a round-necked embroidered blouse. In contrast, Lanka’s design feels far more thoughtfully aligned with the gravity of an epic Itihasa.
- Cultural Accuracy: There are also instances where the film appears to overlook some fundamental cultural sensibilities. In a scene where Bharata visits Ram in the forest, their Guru is positioned behind Bharata, almost like an attendant, while the two brothers sit and converse. In our cultural tradition, the Guru is accorded the highest reverence. It is unimaginable that Sri Ram, the epitome of righteousness (Maryada Purushottam), would ever treat his Guru with such disrespect.
While movies like Baahubali, RRR, Dhurandhar, and Chhaava are filled with goosebump moments, Ramayana: Part 1 unfortunately does not have a single such moment.
Cinema is, of course, primarily a form of entertainment. However, when filmmakers choose to bring an epic of this stature to the screen, they also assume a certain responsibility towards its source material, cultural context, and the expectations of its audience.
On all these fronts, I believe Ramayana: Part 1 falls considerably short of what it could and should have been.
Rating: 5/10
