Who Controls Bharat’s Digital Narrative? Algorithms, Censorship and the IT Rules

The battle over Bharat’s digital space is no longer simply about what citizens are allowed to say. It is increasingly about who decides what citizens get to see.

A political debate can begin with a single social media post, a government decision can become a national controversy through a short video, and an ordinary citizen can reach millions without entering a newsroom. Social media has transformed the relationship between citizens, the State and the media. It has created unprecedented opportunities for democratic participation, but it has also raised an important constitutional question: Who controls Bharat’s digital narrative?

The answer is no longer limited to those who create information. Social media platforms distribute it, algorithms determine its visibility, and governments regulate its circulation. Consequently, the power to shape public opinion is increasingly exercised through digital infrastructure.

The invisible power of algorithms

Social media platforms are not neutral noticeboards. Their algorithms determine which posts appear in users’ feeds, which videos receive recommendations and which discussions become widely visible. These decisions are influenced by engagement, user behaviour, advertising interests and platform policies.

This creates a relatively less visible form of censorship: algorithmic censorship.

Unlike conventional censorship, it does not always involve deleting content or suspending accounts. Sometimes, a post remains online but receives significantly reduced visibility. An investigative report, political criticism or citizen’s account of administrative failure may technically remain accessible while reaching very few people.

The problem is that users may not know whether their content has been restricted, why its reach has declined or whether an automated system has influenced that decision. In Bharat, where social media has become an important source of political information, citizen journalism and public mobilisation, such decisions can influence which issues receive attention and which disappear from public discussion.

The Constitution does not guarantee a particular number of views or impressions. Nevertheless, when digital platforms increasingly determine the visibility of public discourse, their power deserves greater scrutiny.

Regulation: Protection or excessive control?

The government has legitimate reasons to regulate digital platforms. Misinformation, deepfakes, cyberstalking, financial fraud, communal incitement and the circulation of non-consensual private images can cause serious harm.

Bharat’s digital regulatory framework primarily operates through the Information Technology Act, 2000, and the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021. The framework has continued to evolve. The October 2025 amendments modified procedures relating to the removal of unlawful information, while the February 2026 amendments addressed synthetically generated information, including realistic AI-generated audio-visual content.

These developments demonstrate that digital regulation now extends beyond conventional online publications to the technologies through which information is created and distributed. However, a legitimate regulatory objective does not automatically make every restriction constitutionally valid. The real challenge is distinguishing unlawful expression from uncomfortable expression. Political criticism, satire, investigative journalism and unpopular opinions cannot be treated as removable merely because they challenge established narratives or create controversy.

The Constitution’s warning against digital censorship

Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution guarantees citizens freedom of speech and expression. Article 19(2) permits reasonable restrictions on specified grounds, including public order, defamation, security of the State and sovereignty and integrity of India.

This constitutional arrangement establishes an important principle: freedom is the rule, while restrictions must be legally justified.

In Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015), the Supreme Court struck down Section 66A of the Information Technology Act because its vague and excessively broad language violated freedom of expression. The judgment also clarified the importance of legally recognised procedures for requiring intermediaries to remove content. The decision remains significant because it recognises that the internet cannot become a space where vague legal provisions are used to silence unpopular opinions.

Another important development came in September 2024, when the Bombay High Court, in Kunal Kamra v. Union of India, struck down the 2023 amendment providing for a government Fact Check Unit to identify allegedly false or misleading information concerning government business.

The decision highlighted the constitutional dangers of allowing the government to become the decisive authority on the truthfulness of information concerning itself. The government must have the authority to address unlawful content, but that authority cannot become unrestricted power to determine which criticism deserves to remain visible.

Deepfakes and the changing meaning of truth

Artificial intelligence has made digital regulation considerably more complicated. A fabricated video of a political leader, a cloned voice of a public official or an artificially generated recording can circulate widely before its authenticity is questioned.

Such content can damage reputations, influence elections, provoke social tensions and undermine public confidence in institutions. The 2026 amendments to the IT Rules address synthetically generated information through additional platform obligations. Appropriate identification and safeguards can help users distinguish authentic material from deceptive synthetic content.

However, regulation must distinguish harmful deception from legitimate creativity. Political satire, parody, artistic expression and educational content should not automatically be treated as misinformation simply because artificial intelligence has been used to produce them. An excessively broad definition of harmful content risks discouraging legitimate expression alongside genuinely unlawful material.

When private platforms become digital gatekeepers

An often-overlooked aspect of this debate is the influence of private technology companies.

Social media platforms decide what users can publish, which accounts can operate and what content receives prominence. Their community guidelines sometimes impose restrictions beyond the requirements of Bharatiya law. Although these companies are private entities, their enormous influence over public communication gives their decisions significant democratic consequences.

A journalist whose content is repeatedly demoted may struggle to reach an audience. A political discussion restricted by automated moderation may disappear without meaningful explanation. A suspended account may deprive a citizen of an important channel of public participation.

This raises an important question: should platforms exercising such extensive control over public communication be required to demonstrate greater transparency and accountability?

The answer should be affirmative.

Platforms should provide meaningful explanations for content removal, account restrictions and significant visibility limitations. Users should have access to effective appeal mechanisms, particularly where decisions affect journalism, political discussion and public-interest reporting. Automated moderation systems should also face independent scrutiny for accuracy, fairness and discriminatory outcomes.

Regulation without silencing democracy

Bharat does not need an unregulated digital environment. It needs constitutionally responsible digital governance.

Government-directed content restrictions must be based on clear legal authority, written reasons and procedural safeguards. Platforms should disclose meaningful information about their moderation practices and recommendation systems. Independent review mechanisms should examine questionable moderation decisions, particularly those affecting public-interest expression.

Most importantly, there must be a clear distinction between regulating unlawful content and controlling public opinion.

Democracy does not require every online statement to be accurate, agreeable or politically convenient. It requires citizens to retain the freedom to question, disagree, debate and demand accountability within constitutional limits. The greatest danger of algorithmic censorship is not merely that an individual post may disappear. It is that citizens may gradually lose the ability to recognise who is shaping the information they receive.

Bharat’s digital future will not be determined solely by internet speed, the number of users or advances in artificial intelligence. It will also depend on whether citizens retain meaningful control over their freedom to speak and access information. Ultimately, Bharat’s digital narrative should not be controlled by the unchecked authority of either the government or private technology companies.

In a constitutional democracy, the digital narrative must belong, above all, to its people.

-By Kunwar Veer Vikram Pratap Singh

LLB (Allahabad University), LLM in Cyber Law and Cyber Crime Investigation (Uttar Pradesh State Institute of Forensic Science) and UGC NET, Dec. 2025

Subscribe to our channels on WhatsApp, Telegram &  YouTube. Follow us on Twitter and Facebook

Related Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles

Sign up to receive HinduPost content in your inbox
Select list(s):

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.