“Identifying ‘Dimagi Naxals’ Is A Way To Protect Dissent, Not Punish It”, Swarajya, 7 Sep 2026.
“Prime Minister Modi’s use of the phrase dimagi naxal during his Independence Day address has generated quite a controversy, with sceptics in the opposition calling the term a deliberate tool to blur the line between dissent and disloyalty, thereby casting suspicion on anyone critical of government policy.
This article proposes an alternative reading. The construct of dimagi naxal, if understood in its precise form, will in fact help in protecting that line rather than blurring it. The significance of the term should be seen from the fact that, instead of suppressing dissent, it helps us to identify and solidify a very specific category of actors who use the freedom that the Indian Constitution guarantees as a tool to undermine the constitutional order itself.
The inability of informed public discourse to identify this category clearly has critical implications. It may end up either treating every critic as a suspect, which inevitably corrodes free speech and expression, or seeing all critics, regardless of intent and methods, as legitimate. The latter case is equally, if not more, problematic, because the discourse is then incapable of identifying the threats to the freedoms that make debate possible in the first place.
The dimagi naxal framework must therefore be read as an attempt to avoid both failures by drawing the line with precision, and crucially, by making civil society rather than the state the primary institution responsible for holding that line…………”
Read the full article at Swarajya.
